Just a few months in the past I began the thankless job of recapping Secret Invasion, and now, a month after the series ended, I’m nonetheless deeply underwhelmed by the predictable blandness of all the factor. Then, as a result of I used to be hit by a match of nostalgia and since I discover Hayley Atwell absurdly enticing, I began a re-watch of the other grounded spy thriller from Marvel: Agent Carter.
After I completed the second season (the present was unceremoniously cancelled in 2016), I used to be left questioning… how did Secret Invasion handle to fuck up so badly that Agent Carter, a community tv launch with fewer stars, method much less hype, and with out Secret Invasion’s $200 million price range, was higher written, higher paced, and extra fulfilling than Marvel’s most up-to-date spy collection?
For some background, Agent Carter was a short-lived Marvel television series that ran for 2 seasons on ABC from 2015 to 2016. The primary season noticed Hayley Atwell’s Agent Peggy Carter making an attempt to determine herself inside the boy’s membership of the postwar spy group, the Strategic Scientific Reserve (SSR), hoping to clear Howard Stark’s identify after an arms deal goes sideways. It’s a science-fiction dramady couched within the Marvel universe, however with a major character who has no powers, Agent Carter stored each excessive heels firmly on the bottom.
Secret Invasion was touted as “grounded,” and even supposing a lot of the plot was going to undoubtedly circle across the challenge of what to do with the aliens that had clandestinely made Earth their house within the ‘90s, I believed the pitch. A lot of spycraft is combining info and alternative—in the best arms, the premise of a bunch of shapeshifting Skrulls serving to Samuel L. Jackson’s Nick Fury puppet the Avengers into compliance has potential. What we obtained, nevertheless, was a messy world political crises exacerbated by a single man’s hubris—the precise reverse of what Agent Carter was doing.
On the floor, Agent Carter shouldn’t have labored. It’s a interval piece starring a comparatively obscure character who was on display for lower than 20 minutes in Captain America: The First Avenger, a film that was already three years previous on the time of the primary season’s launch. However Agent Carter’s first season’s plot is tight and centered, and the setting, costumes, and even the truth that it consists of an (nearly) completely new solid of characters grow to be a few of Agent Carter’s best strengths.
Agent Carter understood its limitations and labored inside them. It utilized sensible units, restricted particular results, and a few extremely brutal struggle choreography to drag off incredible stunt work. Add to {that a} compelling major character who was an absolute smokeshow and had chemistry with any three characters on display at any given time and you’ve got tv magic. The second season, I’ll totally admit, wasn’t as robust as the primary, however it nonetheless stored up a strong compelling plot and greater than that, I cared. I wished to look at Peggy kick ass and take names, and I didn’t care about what film she may be in subsequent.
With Secret Invasion, the strongest components of the present got here from the performances. Ben Mendelsohn as Talos and Olivia Colman as Sonya Falsworth had been exceptionally good of their roles, and Jackson’s Fury sometimes had some incredible moments. However these small components had been price lower than the sum whole of the collection, which didn’t ship a cohesive, tense, and even fascinating story. We—the viewers—merely knew an excessive amount of.
Agent Carter by no means hurried to offer away Peggy’s secrets and techniques. All the things was peeled again slowly, giving us increasingly of the world as we went alongside. It was paced. A part of this comes from the truth that the MCU was merely smaller seven years in the past. One other a part of that is that it had two seasons to fill, for a complete of 18 episodes; Secret Invasion ran for less than six episodes whole. A part of it is because the collection was by no means anticipated to make a lot of an impression on the films, by advantage of the operate of Marvel tv on the time and the truth that it was set within the early Nineteen Fifties. Agent Carter was given a walled backyard and it took benefit of it. Secret Invasion, sadly, was anticipated to fit into a bigger MCU, fill within the gaps between movies which are already out or are largely carried out, and it suffered for that monitor. Possibly if Secret Invasion had been capable of go off the MCU rails it could have gone someplace fascinating.
The issue with Secret Invasion, and actually the issue that has plagued all the MCU tv collection since WandaVision was launched in 2021, is that these reveals are items of a puzzle. They’re by no means allowed to point out the complete image. They aren’t allowed to be a whole story. There isn’t a ending to any of those reveals, simply extra hooks for writers and administrators to choose up in one other present—not even, essentially, for the viewers to choose up on.
Secret Invasion—and most of those different reveals—really feel each meandering and pointless. There’s some enjoyable available in exploring new origin tales like She-Hulk and Ms. Marvel, however there’s all the time the expectation that even for those who begin a brand new character’s journey in a Marvel present it can ultimately lead right into a Marvel movie. It’s a cycle of limitless content material that weakens each idea, that disenfranchises writers and administrators, and that turns each ending right into a dozen query marks with no passable decision. Secret Invasion is, in the end, a cease hole.
The success of Agent Carter as a present is rooted in the truth that it was allowed to face other than the MCU however nonetheless borrow toys out of its sandbox. It’s familiar, however not stuffed with Easter eggs, winks to the viewers, or flashbacks. It could not impression the films and would have little to no impact on the sacred timeline. It had not one of the concerns of latest reveals and was stronger for it. Secret Invasion had, on paper, every little thing going for it—nice actors, a beneficiant price range, tons of supply materials—and it struck out. However the universe appears to have reached capability, and the Disney+ tv reveals, which may have been enjoyable, experimental trysts within the Marvel backyard, are going to be the a part of the MCU that suffers most.
Agent Carter and Secret Invasion are each streaming on Disney+.
Need extra io9 information? Take a look at when to count on the newest Marvel, Star Wars, and Star Trek releases, what’s subsequent for the DC Universe on film and TV, and every little thing it’s essential to find out about the way forward for Doctor Who.
Trending Merchandise
